We reviewed the medical records and roentgenograms of 1020 patients who
had been managed for adolescent idiopathic scoliosis, between January 1954
and December 1979, with a Milwaukee brace; we wished to determine whether
use of the brace had effectively altered the natural history of the
disease. The findings were considered with respect to a previous study of
727 children who had had comparable curves and had not initially been
managed with the brace but had been followed for progression of the curve,
during the same time-span as that in the current study. Of those 727
patients, 558 (77 percent) had no progression of the curve. The average age
of the 1020 patients at the time that treatment with the brace was begun
was thirteen and one-half years (range, ten to seventeen years). None of
the patients had received any other treatment, and all had been managed
only by the physicians participating in this study. In both the current and
the earlier series, the outcome was considered a failure if the curve had
increased 5 degrees or more; in the patients in the current study, who were
managed with the brace, the outcome was also considered a failure if
operative intervention had been needed. Of the 1020 patients in the current
series, 229 (22 percent) had operative intervention; this rate was higher
in the patients who had a curve of more than 30 degrees at the time of
bracing and in those who had a Risser sign of 0 or 1. The 791 remaining
patients, who were managed with the brace only, had a mild improvement of 1
to 4 degrees at the time that use of the brace was discontinued (the
difference being within the margin of error of measurement). With respect
to curves of between 20 and 39 degrees, the rate of failure was lower in
the current series of patients who had been managed with the brace than in
the earlier series of patients who had not been thus managed but had been
followed for progression. Progression of the curve was found to be related
to the pattern and magnitude of the curve; the age of the patient at the
time of presentation; the Risser sign; and, in girls, the menarchal status.
We recommend that immature adolescents who have a curve of more than 25
degrees and a Risser sign of 0 be managed with a brace immediately, rather
than after progression has been documented.