Acute compartment syndrome in a normal limb is a reported complication of
patient positioning during surgery that can lead to permanent neuromuscular
damage1-7.
The devastating consequences of unrecognized and untreated compartment
syndrome have been well described since 1881, when Volkmann's description was
published8. There
have been several reports of this complication due to special positioning
needs during spine surgery, when it is desirable to attenuate lumbar lordosis
and decompress the abdomen. For example, the so called knee-chest or tuck
position was fraught with complications due to acute compartment syndrome,
which in some instances led to
rhabdomyolysis1-3.
As an alternative, the kneeling position with both hips and knees flexed to
90° (the so-called 90/90 kneeling position) was implemented.
In 1993, Geisler and colleagues reported two cases of acute compartment
syndrome of the leg as a result of the 90/90 kneeling
position4.
Whitesides and Shuster also reported this complication, which was the impetus
for their survey of the 1500 members of the North American Spine
Society6. Among the
respondents, nineteen surgeons reported that twenty-six patients had been
diagnosed with this postoperative complication. The authors concluded that the
90/90 kneeling position can cause lower extremity compartment syndrome and can
lead to neurovascular compromise, and they suggested that this complication is
likely an underreported phenomenon.
In the present clinical investigation, we tried to identify factors that
contribute to the development of acute leg compartment syndrome in patients
undergoing spine surgery. The hypothesis was that intramuscular pressure in
the 90/90 kneeling position is elevated in the dependent anterior compartment
because of the direct compressive load resulting from lower body weight. We
also proposed that heavier patients produce higher applied loads and are at a
greater risk for elevated intramuscular pressures.
Eight healthy male volunteers with a mean age of twenty-seven years (range,
twenty-one to twenty-nine years), a mean weight of 75.1 kg (range, 65.0 to
86.8 kg), and a mean body mass index of 23.7 kg/m2 (range, 21.3 to
25.8 kg/m2) constituted the subject population. All subjects were
healthy, without any history of lower extremity pathology, hypertension, or
peripheral vascular disease. All subjects provided informed written consent
for our investigational procedure, which was approved by our institutional
review board.
Intramuscular pressure measurements in the anterior, lateral, superficial
posterior, and deep posterior compartments of the left leg were recorded
continuously in three different spine surgery positions. These data were
obtained with the use of commercially available slit catheters (Stryker,
Kalamazoo, Michigan) that were placed in each of the four compartments of the
left leg and were connected to arterial pressure transducers for continuous
monitoring. Simultaneously, automated blood pressure measurements were
recorded, with use of an appropriate sized pneumatic cuff, from both the left
arm (heart level) and the left ankle (leg level) every five minutes. Along
with each subject's body weight and height, the applied load or dependent
weight underneath the anterior compartment of the left leg was measured with a
force transducer matrix (Tekscan, Boston, Massachusetts). This system measures
contact force with use of a thin-film force sensor interfaced with a laptop
computer9. The
Tekscan was calibrated with known weights in situ and then was placed
underneath the dependent area of the left leg in each surgical position.
Each subject was placed in each of three spine surgery positions in random
order for twenty minutes, which was thought to be an adequate amount of time
for intramuscular pressure to reach a steady
state7. The three
positions are described below.
Prone with Chest Rolls
The subject was positioned prone on the operating room table with two long
bolsters of identical length supporting the chest. The bolsters were placed
around the lateral aspect of the abdomen and then were curved in to support
the iliac crests and superior aspect of the anterior chest wall. The abdomen
was left free between the bolsters. The knees were slightly flexed by placing
a single pillow underneath the shins. The operating room table was flat
(Fig. 1).
90/90 Kneeling Position
The subject was positioned on an Andrews Spinal Surgery Table (OSI, Union
City, California) in a kneeling position. Care was taken to ensure that both
the hips and the knees were flexed to 90° and that weight was
symmetrically distributed over both anterior compartments. A rectangular foam
pillow was placed beneath the sternum to allow the abdomen to hang free. A gel
pad supported the dependent leg area under the area of the anterior
compartment (Fig. 2).
45/45 Suspended Position
The subject was positioned on a commercially available Jackson Spinal Table
Top (OSI) with both the hips and the knees flexed to 45°. In this
position, the anterior superior iliac crests and the chest were supported by
foam-padded supports while the lower extremities were supported in a vinyl
sling with a single pillow underneath the shins
(Fig. 3).
Statistical Methods
Data were analyzed with StatView statistical software (SAS Institute, Cary,
North Carolina). Statistical analysis was performed with use of
repeated-measures analysis of variance with Bonferroni post hoc corrections
for multiple comparisons. Paired t tests with Bonferroni post hoc corrections
for multiple paired comparisons were used to compare the effects of surgical
positioning on intramuscular pressure for each leg compartment and dependent
weight of the leg. Simple regression analysis was used for correlation data.
All data are presented as the mean and the standard error. The level of
significance was set at p < 0.05.
Anterior compartment intramuscular pressure was highest in the 90/90
kneeling position, with a mean value (and standard error of the mean) of 30.8
± 5.7 mm Hg (Fig. 4).
This value was significantly higher than those in the prone position (13.5
± 1.7 mm Hg; p = 0.014) and the 45/45 suspended position (13.8 ±
1.7 mm Hg; p = 0.012). With the numbers available, there was no difference
between the latter two intramuscular pressures (p = 0.91). In the lateral,
superficial posterior, and deep posterior leg compartments, there was no
difference in intramuscular pressures among the three positions.
In the 90/90 kneeling position, there was a significant correlation between
subject weight and absolute intramuscular pressure in the anterior compartment
(r = 0.72, p = 0.045). With the numbers available, there was no correlation
between subject weight and intramuscular pressure in the other three
compartments.
The mean systolic ankle blood pressure in the prone position was 133
± 3 mm Hg. This value increased significantly to 161 ± 3 mm Hg
in the 90/90 kneeling position (p < 0.0001), and it also increased
significantly from the prone position to a more moderate level of 145 ±
2 mm Hg in the 45/45 suspended position (p < 0.0012).
The value for the diastolic blood pressure at the ankle in the prone
position was 58 ± 2 mm Hg. This value was greater in both the 90/90
kneeling position (99 ± 2 mm Hg; p < 0.0001) and in the 45/45
suspended position (78 ± 3 mm Hg; p = 0.0006). The value for the mean
arterial pressure was 82 ± 2 mm Hg in the prone position, 120 ±
2 mm Hg in the 90/90 kneeling position, and 100 ± 2 mm Hg in the 45/45
suspended position. All three blood pressure measurements were significantly
different (p < 0.001 for all comparisons).
In the prone position the mean difference between the intramuscular
pressure and the diastolic pressure at the ankle was approximately 45 mm Hg in
each leg compartment, whereas in the 90/90 kneeling position this pressure
difference increased significantly to 67.9 ± 6.5 mm Hg in the anterior
compartment (p = 0.0046) and to approximately 85 mm Hg in the lateral,
superficial posterior, and deep posterior compartments (p < 0.0001). In the
45/45 suspended position, the mean difference between the intramuscular
pressure and the diastolic pressure was approximately 65 mm Hg in all leg
compartments, which was significantly higher than the pressure difference of
45 mm Hg measured in the prone position (p < 0.0002)
(Fig. 5). With the numbers
available, the mean difference between the intramuscular pressure and the
diastolic pressure in the anterior compartment in the 90/90 kneeling position
was not significantly different from that in the 45/45 suspended position
(67.9 ± 6.5 compared with 64.5 ± 3.8 mm Hg; p = 0.54).
In the prone position, the mean difference between the intramuscular
pressure and the mean arterial pressure was approximately 70 mm Hg in each of
the four leg compartments. In the 90/90 kneeling position, this value
increased significantly to 88.9 ± 6.7 mm Hg in the anterior compartment
(p = 0.0096), 105.1 ± 3.4 mm Hg in the lateral compartment (p <
0.001), 107.9 ± 5.0 mm Hg in the superficial posterior compartment (p
< 0.001), and 105.0 ± 3.4 mm Hg in the deep posterior compartment (p
< 0.001) (Fig. 6). In the
45/45 suspended position, the mean difference between the intramuscular
pressure and the mean arterial pressure ranged from 86.4 to 88.6 mm Hg in each
compartment and was significantly higher than the values in the prone position
(p < 0.0003). With the numbers available, the mean difference between the
intramuscular pressure and the mean arterial pressure in the anterior
compartment in the 90/90 kneeling position was not different from the
corresponding value in the 45/45 suspended position (88.9 ± 6.7
compared with 86.4 ± 3.3 mm Hg; p = 0.64).
The dependent weights of the left leg were recorded in each surgical
position (Table I). The 90/90
kneeling position had the highest dependent weight (19.3 ± 2.5 kg),
which was significantly higher than the dependent weight in both the prone
position of (2.5 ± 0.4 kg; p = 0.0002) and the 45/45 suspended position
(3.7 ± 1.0 kg; p = 0.0001). With the numbers available, we could not
identify a difference between the dependent weights under the left leg in the
latter two positions (p = 0.18). In the 90/90 kneeling position, there was a
significant correlation between the absolute intramuscular pressure in the
anterior compartment and the dependent weight on that anterior compartment (r
= 0.74, p = 0.037). With the numbers available, the correlation between these
parameters was not significant in the prone position or the 45/45 suspended
position. The dependent weight of the left leg and the subject weight were
strongly correlated (r = 0.92, p = 0.001).
One subject complained of mild aching at the site of the deep posterior
slit catheter but was able to complete the study without incident. No other
subject had any notable complaints during the study. There were no
post-procedural complications in the study.
Previous studies in which absolute intramuscular pressure has been used as
a predictor of compartment syndrome have suggested that pressures of >30 mm
Hg may predispose a patient to acute compartment
syndrome10-12.
However, recently it has been suggested that intramuscular pressures relative
to blood pressure should be considered in an attempt to incorporate an
estimation of perfusion
pressure7,13-20.
This was demonstrated in a recent study of the normal leg in the hemilithotomy
position that suggested that limb elevation increases the potential risk for
acute compartment
syndrome7.
In the present study, large increases in diastolic ankle blood pressure
were produced by lowering the leg from the prone position to the 45/45
suspended position and the 90/90 kneeling position. Hence, our relative
pressure data were well above the proposed theoretical criteria for the
development of a compartment syndrome, which are generally within 30 mm Hg of
the diastolic pressure and within 30 to 40 mm Hg of the mean arterial
pressure18,20-24.
We believe that, in the 90/90 kneeling position, the local compressive forces
due to dependent weight are large enough that they redirect blood flow and
create local hypoperfusion, thus counteracting the protective effects of
elevated blood pressure in these positions.
Operative conditions also make it difficult to establish accurate
intramuscular pressure threshold values for tissue damage. Experimentally,
hemorrhagic hypotension reduces the intramuscular pressure threshold for acute
compartment syndrome. For example, shock experiments have demonstrated that
intramuscular pressures of only 20 mm Hg can cause substantial muscle
necrosis, implying that intraoperative conditions that expose patients to
hypotension make them more susceptible to tissue
damage11,25,26.
In addition, the amount of time that tissues experience compromised
perfusion due to elevated intramuscular pressures is another crucial variable.
A definite time threshold has not been established for tissue damage,
partially because it has been shown that higher pressures result in faster and
more severe
damage10,22,27-29
and transient elevations in intramuscular pressures are tolerated without
consequences30.
However, nerve and muscle damage occurs histologically between six to eight
hours at intramuscular pressures of 30 mm
Hg10,11.
In the North American Spine Society survey by Whitesides and Shuster, the
average operative time for patients in whom compartment syndrome developed was
6.5 hours (range, 3.5 to seven
hours)6.
The present study does have limitations, and it may not completely reflect
the conditions of the dependent anterior leg compartment during spine surgery.
First, we used a limited time-course of twenty minutes in each position, which
is much shorter than that associated with spine surgery. It has been shown
experimentally that intramuscular pressure in surgical positioning experiences
a slow increase31.
In addition, we did not want the volunteers in our study to be extended beyond
the threshold of tissue compression and hypoperfusion, which can lead to the
ischemia-edema cycle that occurs in acute compartment
syndrome32. Second,
the characteristics of our subjects were dissimilar to those of the patients
in the North American Spine Society survey. Our subjects had a mean weight of
75 kg, compared with 116 kg for the patients in the survey. This finding is
relevant as our data demonstrated a significant correlation between subject
weight and applied load to the dependent anterior compartment with
intramuscular pressure. In addition, there was a potential for voluntary
muscular guarding because the subjects in our study were unanesthetized, which
may have led to underestimation of the applied load on the dependent
compartments. Furthermore, the subjects in the present study did not have
active blood loss and intraoperative hypotension and had no comorbidities.
Clinically, suspicion of acute compartment syndrome in the postoperative
setting is important because prompt diagnosis and treatment affect outcome.
Diagnosis is primarily made by identifying persistent myoneural pain along
with diminished motor and sensory function in the muscles and nerves contained
in the affected compartment. During the postoperative care of patients
undergoing spine surgery, this diagnosis is confounded by a low index of
suspicion, postoperative narcotic usage, and postoperative motor and sensory
findings that, although consistent with a compartment syndrome, may also be
consistent with having had spine surgery. These motor and sensory findings can
include persistent preoperative symptoms or can arise from nerve root injury,
hardware impingement on neurological structures, or neuropraxia due to
positioning. These conditions are typically treated with expectant management,
which is in stark contrast to the performance of emergent fasciotomy for the
treatment of an acute compartment syndrome. Because of the difficulty in
postoperative diagnosis, awareness and prevention of this complication is of
great importance.
In conclusion, during preoperative planning in the case of a heavier
patient or a patient for whom there is the potential for a prolonged operative
time, the surgeon should consider the 45/45 suspended position on a Jackson
frame instead of the 90/90 kneeling position because of the potential for
acute compartment syndrome. Our data provide strong evidence that the 45/45
suspended position is better able to mitigate this potentially devastating
complication. In the case of a patient with appropriate postoperative
symptoms, a suspicion of acute compartment syndrome due to surgical
positioning should be maintained to prevent the development of permanent
sequelae. ?